Mary Trump's shocking book on the president is not so shocking for psychiatrist Trump on the sofa Justin Frank

He wrote three books heads of psychoanalysis. Unlike his colleague shrinking Mary Trump, he never met any of them. Does it matter

Mary Trump's shocking book on the president is not so shocking for psychiatrist Trump on the sofa Justin Frank

He wrote three books heads of psychoanalysis. Unlike his colleague shrinking Mary Trump, he never met any of them. Does it matter

In a market saturated with books about President Trump, a new biting version of his niece Marie Trump was launched as one of the best sellers - partly because Trumps tried to stop its release, partly because it introduces something new: a psychologist who relies on a personal experience to draw a family portrait and explain Presidential Psychology.

One particularly interested reader: psychiatrist DC Justin Frank, author of Trump's 2018 sofa book. Unlike Mary Trump, Frank never met the president. Instead, he based his book, like his previous book Bush on the Sofa and Obama on the Sofa, on a controversial technique called Applied Psychoanalysis, which involves close readings of resumes, speeches, and interviews to come up with a patient's theory.

So how did it feel to read a fellow who has shrinking real experience with unintended analysis and his messy family? "I thought it was amazing," says Frank. "I thought it was beautifully written. She has a sense of humor and she is aware."

More than that, he says, he did not come kicking himself because he was missing something. "It basically proved the study of applied psychoanalysis because there was not a single surprise in terms of Trump's psychodynamics. Everything I wrote about, I had already written about."

Frank, who attributed parts of Trump's makeup to growing up with a distant and cold mother, says that some details of the new book deepened his understanding, especially the impact of her health problems. "I knew she was sick more than I thought after her surgery," says Frank. "[Mary Trump] believes that he was in good contact with her in the first two years of his life, and the loss was sudden and shocking."

As for Fred Trump's authoritarian, the main focus of Mary Trump's book, Frank says he knew that the young Donald was terrified of his father, but he was shocked with the cruelty of later scenes that ridiculed the aging Sheikh Patriarch.

He says, "I wrote that he had an internal struggle between being a builder and being ruined." "And that the devastating part of his character has basically triumphed, and he still wins, how he handled Covid, and how he attacks Dr. Fauci. He is determined to do it, unconsciously, which revolves around destroying everything his father built, and unconsciously he is destroying America In terms of its symbolic element for him, which is the concept of the founding father. "

He also revealed the story of Mary Trump, who claims that the future president paid someone to take his standardized tests. “I have written about an undiagnosed educational disability that no one has ever written about before. I discovered this through my research and wrote about a whole chapter on that in my book” which touched on shame and lying - perhaps including lying about who took the SAT - To cover it up.

Mary Trump's experience is supposed to end with her uncle running. On the other hand, Frank, 77 years old and still a practicing psychoanalyst in the capital's Palisades neighborhood, has a book franchise that can grow every time the White House gets a new concern. Will he make sure to put Joe Biden on the virtual sofa? He says the tragic Biden family history will make the work exciting.

He says, “I will start writing about it through my previous two perceptions, and I will try not to let that dominate the work. The first is that I did not outperform Anita Hill,” which accused Supreme Court candidate Clarence Thomas of sexual harassment and ruptured embers by the Biden committee during confirmation sessions. "But the other side is the idea that sadness is a growth vitamin."

Frank is unlikely to have a professional competition for this book. Under the "Goldwater Rule", which was adopted after a number of psychiatrists essentially declared the presidential candidate for the Republican Party in 1964 as nuts, the American Psychological Association prohibits members from diagnosing people they did not see as sick. Frank does not face such restrictions: he left the assembly while he published his first books on the sofa. Today, it is believed that the Goldwater base should be abolished.

BOOKSDONALD TRUMPJOE BIDENJUSTIN FRANKMARY TRUMPMENTAL HEALTHPOLITICS